Medical Malpractice Lawyer

Less Invasive Surgery for Cervical Cancer is Causing More Deaths

Minimally invasive surgery for early stage cervical cancer has grown in popularity since 2006. Unlike traditional surgery, which involves a cut in the lower abdomen, the minimally invasive surgery only requires a small incision for a camera and instruments. Because patients recover faster, “laparoscopic surgery has gained popularity despite a lack of rigorous long-term studies.”

According to studies, this practice turns out to be worse than standard surgery, with a higher death rate, “challenging standard practice and the “less is more” approach to treating cervical cancer.”(Myrtle Beach Online,

The first study was conducted at more than 30 sites worldwide, and involved more than 600 women. Half had their uterus removed through “open approach”, the other half had the minimally invasive method.

“After 4 ½ years, the rate of those still living without disease was 86 percent with less invasive surgery and 96 percent with traditional surgery.”

The second study looked at 2,461 women who had radical hysterectomies between 2010 and 2013 for cervical cancer. The conclusion showed that 9.1% of the women who had the minimally invasive surgery died after four years, compared to 5.3% with traditional surgery.

Experts are not sure why the minimally invasive surgery has failed to measure up. They suspect there may be something with the tools or method that spreads the cancer cells to the abdominal cavity. There’s a chance that the “carbon dioxide gas used to inflate the abdomen during the minimally invasive surgery could also be playing a role.”

Some hospitals went back to performing traditional hysterectomies after these studies were presented.

What are the Risk Factors for Cervical Cancer?

  • Infection with Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) is the number one risk factor for cervical cancer. HPV is responsible for two-thirds of cervical cancer cases.
  • Immunosuppression
  • Multiple births
  • Cigarette smoking
  • Long-term use of oral contraceptives


Two vaccines have been approved by the FDA to prevent HPV.

  • Gardisil – recommended for females between 9 and 26 years of age
  • Cervarix – recommended for females 10 to 25 years of age

Early Detection

  • HPV test
  • Pap test – screens for abnormal cells on the cervix

Ages 21 – 29: Pap test every 3 years

Ages 30 – 65: Pap test plus HPV test every 5 years or Pap test alone every 3 years.

Ages 65 +: No screening recommended for women who have had normal Pap test results in previous years.

South Carolina Statistics:

“South Carolina ranked 19th in the nation for cervical cancer incidence and 14th for cervical cancer mortality from 2011 to 2015.” (SCDHEC,

Due to Pap test screening, cervical cancer incidence and mortality have substantially fallen in the past several decades. Cervical cancer is not in the top ten for new cancer cases or for mortality in South Carolina women.

Cervical cancer is treatable if diagnosed in the early stages. Between the years 2011 and 2015 in South Carolina, only 44% of cervical cancers were diagnosed in the early stages of the disease.

The mortality rates between 2011 and 2015 were slightly higher in South Carolina at 2.5, compared to the United States at 2.3.


If you or someone you care about has suffered because of medical negligence, please schedule your free consultation by calling the Law Offices of David L. Hood at (843) 491-6025 or filling out our brief online contact form.

We know how difficult it can be to deal with the immediate and long-term effects of a serious malpractice-related injury. At the Law Offices of David L. Hood, we work hard to make things simple for you. After a free case evaluation, if we believe we can help you and your family, Medical Malpractice Attorney David L. Hood, co-counsel, and our team of experts will vigorously pursue your case to get you the best result we can achieve. Let us put our years of experience to work for you!

*Clients are not liable for any expenses, unless there is a recovery in their case; however, if there is a recovery in their case, clients will be liable for expenses. Attorney’s fees are based on a percentage of the recovery, which will be computed before deducting expenses.

Other online references used for this document: